Why ‘Just Relax’ Advice Fails – How to Destress Using Your Nervous System
“A little nonsense now and then, is cherished by the wisest men.”
On the surface, it looks as though you have it under control. Your calendar is full and colour-coded, the people around you know you as someone who delivers, and you navigate the pressures of work and life with apparent steadiness. You are the person who keeps moving when others hesitate, who remembers the detail, who closes the loop. But this external composure conceals an internal world that rarely sits still. Some days it hums with restless energy, a sense of urgency you can’t quite name. On other days, it feels dense and flat, as though each action costs twice as much as it should. Your mind is alert to every possible demand before it arrives. You carry the weight of responsibility not just in what you do, but in the constant readiness to respond. This shifting internal landscape, the interplay of your nervous system, emotional tone, and energy reserves, is invisible to most people, yet it shapes every experience you have.
And then, in a moment of well-meaning conversation, someone offers a fix. “You should try yoga.” “A hot bath works wonders.” “Take a break, you’ll feel better.” The suggestions are familiar, wrapped in the authority of repetition, the things people say because they’ve read them, heard them, or tried them themselves. You want to believe them. You can picture it: stepping barefoot into a warm studio, lowering yourself into scented water, closing your laptop for an entire long weekend. You’ve done these things before, sometimes with real relief, a loosening in your chest, a mind that softens enough to let the world in. But there have been other times, and you remember them clearly, when these same activities left you no lighter than before. The bath made you fidget. The yoga class seemed to amplify the noise in your head. The time away gave you distance from your inbox but none from yourself.
It is in those moments that doubt creeps in. If the activities designed to soothe don’t work, perhaps you are beyond reach. Perhaps you are wired in a way that resists restoration. Yet the truth is both less dramatic and more powerful: whether something calms or unsettles you depends less on the activity itself than on the state you are in when you begin. Your nervous system is not a static system; it is a dynamic, predictive network that continually scans for safety and adjusts its responses accordingly. An activity that is perfectly matched to your current state can help you find equilibrium. One that is mismatched too still when you are restless, too activating when you are depleted can tip you further off balance.
This is the missing piece in much of the advice we are given about stress and self-care. The conversation is almost always about the what: which practice, which routine, which tool. It rarely begins with the where: where you are starting from, internally. Yet that starting point matters more than anything. If you want genuine relief, not just a brief distraction, the question is not “What’s the best way to relax?” but “What does my internal state need right now?” When you begin there, the activity becomes a response to your inner world, not a prescription handed down from someone else’s experience. And that is when stress relief stops being another item on a list and starts becoming something that works.
Read: Successful But Unfulfilled? Neuroscience Reveals What’s Missing
Redefining Productivity: Why Overworking Is a Nervous System Response, Not Virtue
✍️ Ready to take this further?
The Design a Life You Love Journal offers 30 days of guided reflection, neuroscience-backed prompts, and identity work to help shift patterns and align with a more intentional life.
👉 Explore the Journal here
The Comforting but False Promise of Universal Stress-Relief
There is a certain comfort in believing that calm can be prescribed. That if you simply follow the right sequence, the walk, the deep breathing, the scented candle, the bath, you will reliably arrive at a state of ease. This is the appeal of the self-care checklist: a promise of certainty in a world where so much feels unpredictable. The lists are everywhere in glossy wellness magazines, corporate “resilience” workshops, and the curated lives of social media influencers. The message is always the same: stress can be solved with a fixed set of actions, and if those actions fail to deliver, the fault must lie with you. It is a narrative designed to soothe by offering control, but it is built on an incomplete understanding of what stress is and how the nervous system works.
This formulaic approach persists because, narrowly, it does sometimes work. If, by chance, you choose an activity that happens to align with your internal state, you may feel better afterwards. The run that burns through excess adrenaline after a morning of difficult conversations; the coffee with a trusted friend that draws you out of isolation just when you need connection; the quiet half-hour of reading that meets you at the exact moment your mind is ready to downshift. These moments are powerful and worth remembering; they form the personal stories we tell about what “works” for us. But they also create a kind of cognitive trap. We forget that the activity itself was not the sole cause of our relief. It was the match between what we did and the state we were in that made the difference. That same run, that same coffee, that same quiet could have left us more agitated, lonely, or restless on a different day.
The promise of a universal stress-relief solution collapses under the weight of this reality. No two internal states are identical, even within the same person. Your nervous system is as individual as your fingerprint, shaped by your history, your environment, your level of fatigue, your current load of responsibilities, and your recent experiences. It is constantly recalibrating, responding to subtle shifts in physiology, emotion, and context. The activity that served you yesterday may be entirely irrelevant to the state you inhabit today. When the “one-size-fits-all” recommendation fails, it is not a sign that you lack discipline or that the practice has lost its magic; it is simply that it was never designed for this version of you.
The deeper problem with prescriptive relaxation is that it subtly trains us to outsource our self-awareness. We start to trust the list more than we trust our bodies. We persist with an activity because it is what we “should” do, even when our lived experience tells us it is not helping. In doing so, we override the very signals that could guide us towards something more effective. The checklist becomes another demand to meet, another measure of success or failure, and the pursuit of calm begins to mirror the same pressure that created our stress in the first place. The truth, though less tidy, is more liberating: there is no single formula for calm. There is only the ongoing practice of meeting yourself where you are, choosing not from habit, but from a clear reading of what your internal world needs in this moment.
Read: Repair, Rewire, Remember, Return: A Nervous System-Led Framework for Real Transformation
Design a Life You Love: How to Align Your Inner World and Outer Life
The Science of Why the Same Activity Can Help or Hinder
Beneath the surface of every experience you have, your brain is running a constant, quiet calculation. Its job is not to make you happy or even calm, it is to keep you alive. That means it is always predicting what you will need next, and adjusting your body to meet that prediction. This process, known as allostasis, is why your nervous system is never static. It shifts in response to what it senses from the tangible (temperature changes, hunger, movement) to the intangible (tone of voice, a memory triggered by a smell, the anticipation of an upcoming meeting). Whether a particular activity brings you relief or leaves you restless depends on how well it matches what your system has already prepared you for.
This is why one day a run can feel like a release and the next it can feel like a punishment. If you have been in prolonged sympathetic activation that heightened fight-or-flight energy, your system is primed for movement. In that state, burning through adrenaline with physical exertion can return you to a calmer baseline. But if you try to sit completely still in meditation while in this state, your body may interpret the stillness as a mismatch, even as a potential threat. Your mind races, your muscles twitch, and instead of calming, you feel more trapped inside your agitation.
The same is true in reverse. When you are in dorsal vagal shutdown, the low-energy, withdrawn state where your system is conserving resources, stillness can feel like sliding further into the fog. You may think, I should rest, but the kind of rest that helps here is not the complete absence of movement; it is the gentle reactivation that signals safety. Sunlight on your face, a slow walk around the block, a warm shower these are small cues that invite your system to return to engagement. If, instead, you push yourself into vigorous exercise in this state, your body may experience it as an overwhelming demand, deepening the sense of depletion.
The ability to sense these nuances is called interoception, the skill of reading the internal signals your body sends. Strong interoceptive awareness is not about obsessing over every sensation, but about being able to distinguish between “I’m tired and need to rest” and “I’m tired because I’ve been still too long and need to move.” It’s a skill that can be honed, but in modern life, it is often dulled. We learn to override our signals in favour of schedules, commitments, and routines. We go for a run because it’s Tuesday, not because our bodies are asking for it. We meditate because our morning habit tracker tells us to, not because we have checked in with what our state requires.
When you see your nervous system as a dynamic, context-dependent system, not a fixed machine, the logic of “no activity is inherently de-stressing” becomes unavoidable. Yoga is not universally calming. A bath is not universally restorative. Conversation is not universally connecting. All of these things can be exactly what you need, or exactly what you don’t, depending on the state you are in when you begin. This is not a flaw in the activity or you; it is simply how a predictive, adaptive system operates. Relief comes not from finding the one perfect practice, but from matching your choice to your current state. And that begins with the willingness to pause, to notice, and to act from that noticing instead of from habit.
Read: The Invisible Forces Shaping Your Identity: How Environment, Neuroscience, and Human Design Impact You
How Emotions Are Constructed - Neuroscience Meets Human Design
✍️ Ready to take this further?
The Design a Life You Love Journal offers 30 days of guided reflection, neuroscience-backed prompts, and identity work to help shift patterns and align with a more intentional life.
👉 Explore the Journal here
A State-First Approach to Stress Relief
If the nervous system is always in motion, recalibrating moment to moment, then the real work of finding calm begins before you do anything at all. It begins with the pause, a deliberate interruption to the habit of rushing straight to a solution. Most of us are not used to that pause. We are conditioned to reach for the thing we know, the thing that worked last time, or the thing we have been told will help. We mistake speed for effectiveness and prescription for certainty. But when you act before you understand where you are starting from, you are aiming without a target. The pause is where you step out of the reflex and take a reading not of your to-do list, not of your environment, but of your internal state. That reading is the compass. Without it, even the most well-meaning action can lead you further from what you need.
This kind of self-reading is subtle. It asks you to notice the difference between restless energy and genuine motivation, between mental fog and physical depletion, between the desire for connection and the need for solitude. It is about developing the skill of interoception, not as a technical term, but as a lived ability to recognise the weather inside your own body and mind. At first, it can feel awkward, even inconvenient, to stop and sense. You might hear the voice that says, Just get on with it. But the more you practice, the more you begin to catch the signals you used to miss. You notice the hum in your muscles that means movement will help, or the heavy pull in your chest that says today you need warmth and stillness. These small recognitions change everything, because they allow your choice of activity to be a response to reality rather than an echo of habit.
From that place of awareness, the activity you choose becomes less about what you “should” do and more about what will meet you where you are. On a day when your system is charged and alert, grounding might mean turning down the lights, letting your breath slow, and bringing your focus to something small and steady. On a day when your system is flat and withdrawn, regulation might mean stepping into the sun, listening to music that nudges your energy upward, or engaging in a conversation that feels safe and enlivening. These are not prescriptions; they are possibilities that you learn to test and adapt, discovering over time which patterns match your state and which do not. It is a living process, responsive rather than rigid, and it evolves as you do.
In time, this “state-first” way of approaching stress relief becomes more than a tool you reach for when you are already frayed. It becomes a way of living inside your own life with greater accuracy. You start to make smaller, earlier adjustments, catching the shift in your state before it tips into overwhelm. You notice that recovery is not something you have to schedule for a weekend or a holiday; it is something you can weave into the rhythm of your days. And with each time you meet your internal world as it is, rather than forcing it into the shape of a pre-determined plan, you build not only resilience but a quiet confidence in your capacity to sustain yourself, no matter what the day demands.
Read: Why Success Makes Us Sick: A Neuroscience-Based Redefinition for Ambitious Professionals
Scarcity Rewired: How to Break Free from Survival Mode
✍️ Ready to take this further?
The Design a Life You Love Journal offers 30 days of guided reflection, neuroscience-backed prompts, and identity work to help shift patterns and align with a more intentional life.
👉 Explore the Journal here
Why This Matters Beyond “Feeling Better”
It would be easy to frame this as another conversation about self-care, as though pausing to read your internal state is simply another way to make sure you “get enough rest.” But a state-first approach is not about inserting moments of relaxation into an otherwise unsustainable life. It is about changing the way you live and work so that you are no longer constantly working against yourself. When you ignore your state and default to mismatched solutions out of habit, expectation, or pressure, you create friction within your system. That friction doesn’t always announce itself loudly. It creeps in quietly, tightening the body, narrowing your perspective, making it harder to access the clarity and creativity you rely on. You might still meet your deadlines, deliver your presentations, and appear steady to the outside world, but beneath the surface, you are drawing from reserves that are not being replenished. The cost of that depletion shows up later in the quality of your thinking, in your ability to adapt to change, in whether you still have the energy to create a life you want to be living, not just a life you can maintain.
Nowhere is this more visible than in leadership. The pressure to hold a vision, make decisions under uncertainty, and maintain composure for the sake of those you lead is constant. In this position, your internal state becomes part of the environment for everyone else. A leader who is carrying unacknowledged tension into a room will, without meaning to, transmit that unease. People pick it up in tone, timing, body language, even in the quality of silence. The same is true for steadiness. Regulation is contagious; so is dysregulation. When you are attuned to yourself, you can feel when your clarity is slipping before it unravels in your communication. You can sense when a room needs more energy, when it needs you to slow the pace, and when it needs you to create space for others to think. This is what presence truly is: not a performance of calm, but an alignment between your inner state and your outer expression that others can feel. It is a leadership capacity built on precision, not performance, and it is sustained by the ongoing work of knowing where you are starting from before you act.
The same principle plays out in personal relationships, though often in subtler ways. When you are unaware of your state, you may find yourself snapping when you mean to listen, withdrawing when you long for closeness, or overexplaining when silence would do. You leave interactions wondering why they didn’t go the way you intended, forgetting that what you carried into them set the tone before a word was spoken. A state-first approach allows you to interrupt this cycle. When you can recognise the tension in your shoulders before you step into a conversation, you have the choice to ground yourself so your words land differently. When you can feel the pull towards withdrawal, you can discern whether it is a genuine need for solitude or avoidance in disguise. Over time, this changes the very texture of your connections. They become steadier, less about navigating the fallout of missed signals, and more about building trust through clarity, the kind of trust that grows when you can name what you need instead of asking others to guess.
And beyond leadership or relationships, there is another realm where this matters profoundly: your ability to think expansively. When your nervous system is stuck in survival mode, your brain’s priority is not innovation or strategy; it is safety. Your attention narrows to immediate demands, familiar patterns, and the path of least resistance. Creativity becomes harder to access, and long-term vision fades into the background. By learning to match your actions to your state, you widen the window in which your best thinking can occur. You create the physiological conditions for insight, problem-solving, and perspective. This is not about chasing a constant state of calm; calm is not always what a situation requires. It is about cultivating adaptability so that you can shift into the state that best serves the moment, whether that is focus, openness, groundedness, or mobilisation. And in doing so, you protect the mental and emotional resources that make your work not just effective, but meaningful.
This is why a state-first approach is not a wellness trend or a personal indulgence. It is a core discipline for anyone who wants to sustain their capacity in a complex, demanding world. It is a way of working with yourself, rather than against yourself, so that you can meet the moment without losing the parts of you that matter most. It is how you ensure that your energy, attention, and presence are available not only for the urgent tasks in front of you, but for the life you are here to live. And when you practice it long enough, it stops being a technique you apply in moments of strain, and becomes a way of inhabiting your life, one where you are no longer guessing at what might help, but moving with a kind of grounded certainty that whatever the day brings, you will know how to meet it.
Read: The Transformative Power of Awe: How Wonder Rewires Your Brain and Expands Your Life
Rewiring Your Brain for Change: How to Break Free from Mental Rigidity
✍️ Ready to take this further?
The Design a Life You Love Journal offers 30 days of guided reflection, neuroscience-backed prompts, and identity work to help shift patterns and align with a more intentional life.
👉 Explore the Journal here
The Practice of Meeting Yourself
The truth that no activity is inherently de-stressing is not simply a reframing of self-care; it is a deeper invitation to return to yourself. Not to the curated image of composure you present to others, or the version of yourself shaped by habit and expectation, but to the living, shifting reality of your inner state in this exact moment. It asks you to pause before acting, to interrupt the automatic reach for a familiar solution, and to notice with honesty and without judgement what is actually happening inside. This is not a skill you acquire once and then tick off a list; it is an ongoing practice. Some days, the pause will feel clear and purposeful, and you will match your next step perfectly to your state. Other days, you will misread yourself or override the signals entirely. But each time you choose to pause, each time you take that reading before acting, you strengthen the link between your awareness and your actions. That is how this practice takes root.
It is a practice that stands in direct contrast to the culture’s preference for certainty and quick fixes. We are sold the idea that if we just find the right technique, the right schedule, the right sequence of actions, balance will follow. A state-first approach asks you to relinquish that illusion to trade the neatness of a checklist for the more demanding but ultimately more reliable security of self-trust. This requires tolerating the discomfort of it depends; accepting that your needs are not only personal, but fluid. It asks you to see value not in replicating yesterday’s solution, but in recognising that what serves you today might be entirely different. The reward for that courage is not a life without stress such a life does not exist but a life in which stress no longer dictates your choices. You have the means to respond to it, work with it, and recover from it without eroding yourself in the process.
Over time, this way of living changes your relationship with yourself at a fundamental level. You stop viewing your capacity as something that is fixed, to be protected or preserved at all costs, and start seeing it as something that can be regenerated and expanded through alignment. You begin to trust that you can meet the demands of your life without sacrificing the parts of you that make it worth living. This trust does not come from having the “right” activity at hand, but from knowing that you can read your state accurately and respond to it wisely, whatever the circumstances. And in that trust lies a different kind of resilience one built not on holding everything together until it breaks, but on the confidence that you can restore yourself again and again without losing what is essential.
Read: Labels Are Not Identity: Expanding Beyond the Boxes We Are Given
Reclaim Your Signature Self: How Neuroscience & Human Design Unlock Authentic Living
✍️ Ready to take this further?
The Design a Life You Love Journal offers 30 days of guided reflection, neuroscience-backed prompts, and identity work to help shift patterns and align with a more intentional life.
👉 Explore the Journal here
From Insight to Practice
Understanding the principle is one thing; living it, day after day, in the middle of your actual life, is another. In the abstract, the idea of pausing, taking a reading of your state, and then acting from that place feels clear. But in the press of deadlines, decisions, and competing demands, it is easy to slip back into default patterns to reach for the activity you’ve always chosen, to override your body’s cues in service of urgency, to forget that you have another way of working with yourself. This is why the skill of state-first living is best built through sustained practice and deliberate support, until it becomes instinctive.
This is the focus of the Design A Life You Love 16-week coaching programme: not adding more to your life, but rewiring the way you approach it from the inside out. Across our work together, we build an inner architecture that allows you to meet your days with clarity and adaptability, grounded in neuroscience, behavioural strategy, and deep self-leadership. We examine the patterns that have kept you working against your state, and replace them with systems that support your nervous system while still enabling you to perform and lead at a high level. By the end, you leave not only with insight, but with the lived capacity to sustain yourself without waiting for a crisis to force you into change.
For moments when you don’t need the full arc of a coaching programme, but you do need depth and precision, the Office Hours sessions offer a concentrated two-hour space to untangle a single knot. This could be a leadership decision you’ve been circling without resolution, a point of friction in your work that keeps draining you, or a period of transition where you want to align your actions with your true priorities. These sessions are designed to cut through noise and deliver clarity you can act on immediately, a way of meeting your state and your challenge head-on.
And for those who prefer a quieter, self-guided entry point, the Design A Life You Love Journal provides a daily structure for refining your interoceptive awareness. Through prompts, reflections, and micro-actions, it helps you notice the subtle shifts in your state, experiment with different responses, and track what works for you over time. It’s a simple but powerful tool for embedding this practice into the rhythm of your days, so that checking in with yourself becomes as habitual as checking your email.
However, you choose to approach it through intensive coaching, focused problem-solving, or daily reflection, the aim is the same: to turn the concept of “meeting yourself where you are” from a passing insight into a way of being. When you know how to read your state and respond accordingly, you stop chasing the perfect conditions to feel well. You create those conditions from within, moment by moment, and that changes not just how you manage stress, but how you live.
Work With Me
If you’re ready to stop overidentifying with your output and start leading, creating, and living from a grounded sense of self, let’s work together:
💡 Book a Consultation – A 1:1 conversation to explore long-term coaching. This is for professionals, creatives, and leaders ready to repattern deeply, integrate sustainable strategies, and build a life that aligns from the inside out.
📖 Buy the Journal – Start with The Design a Life You Love Journal, a neuroscience-led 30-day guide to rewiring internal safety, agency, and alignment. Use code NEWSLETTER at checkout for a subscriber-only discount.
📆Join Office Hours – A low-pressure space for in-the-moment coaching, strategy calibration, and nervous system support.
If this supported you…
I write these articles to help you reconnect with yourself and create meaningful change from the inside out.
If something here resonated, shifted something, or helped you feel a little less alone, you're welcome to support this work.
Your donation helps keep the writing independent, ad-free, and grounded in care.
Recommended Reading:
1. How Emotions Are Made: The Secret Life of the Brain Lisa Feldman Barrett. A foundational text for understanding how the brain constructs emotional experience and why the same situation can feel completely different depending on your state. It reframes emotion not as hardwired reactions but as predictions shaped by past experience directly relevant to why no activity is inherently de-stressing.
2. The Extended Mind: The Power of Thinking Outside the Brain Annie Murphy Paul. Explores how our thinking and decision-making are shaped by our bodies, environments, and relationships. Offers a research-backed lens on how to create conditions internally and externally that support clarity, creativity, and regulation.
3. The Polyvagal Theory in Therapy Deb Dana. An accessible, practical exploration of polyvagal theory that translates the science of nervous system states into daily life. Dana’s work provides concrete ways to notice and shift your state, which is the essence of state-first living.
4. Peak Mind: Find Your Focus, Own Your Attention, Invest 12 Minutes a Day Amishi Jha. A neuroscience-based guide to training attention so you can remain present and adaptable under pressure. Jha’s research offers a clear bridge between mindfulness, performance, and the ability to respond to your state in real time.
THIS POST MAY CONTAIN AFFILIATE LINKS
Continue the Work: Journal and Coaching Options
The Design a Life You Love Journal
This 30-day self-guided journey combines neuroscience, Human Design, and strategy to help you rebuild your boundaries from within. Through daily prompts, embodiment practices, and Future Self visioning, you’ll rewire the internal cues that shape your external choices.
→ Explore the Journal in The Studio
Private Coaching for Nervous System-Aligned Leadership
If you’re navigating a personal or professional threshold, coaching offers a deeper integration process grounded in cognitive neuroscience, trauma-aware strategy, and your unique Human Design.
This is high-level, intentional coaching for people who want to live, lead, and decide from within.
More Articles to Explore:
Labels Are Not Identity: Expanding Beyond the Boxes We Are Given
Reclaim Your Signature Self: How Neuroscience & Human Design Unlock Authentic Living
The Future Self as a Mental Model: How to Transform Your Life
The Science of Self-Trust: Rewiring the Brain for Confidence, Clarity, and Sturdy Leadership
Identity and Neuroplasticity: Shifting Your Brain Toward the Person You Desire to Be
